Humanist Perspectives: issue 162, Justice & Revenge
Justice & Revenge
issue 162, Autumn 2007

-
editorial & special report
Humanism & Forgiveness - To punish or to let go? Humanists ought to exemplify a forgiving attitude.
-
reflections of a humanist
Punishment or Prevention? - Our attitude toward crime is flawed by too much reliance on punishment and incarceration, and too little attention to the causes of crime.
- letters from our readers
-
- Alexandre Brassard of York University challenges Humanist Perspectives’ attacks on the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council (SSHRC); Patrick Walden of TRIUMF replies.
- Joyce Tomboulian questions Humanist Perspectives’ thoughts on “Rethinking Humanism”; Gary Bauslaugh replies.
- Max Wallace argues that in “Rethinking Humanism” we need to pay more attention to the privileges accorded religions in supposedly secular societies.
feature
- Vengeance is Mine
- Ian Johnston discusses the popularity of the revenge theme in film and literature, how revenge stories are structures, and why they are imaginatively appealing — they are a “powerful wish fulfillment fantasy”.
-
Forgiveness:
The Weak Get Even & The Great Get Over It - June Callwood was one of Canada’s leading journalists. This is one of her last essays.
- Getting Even? The Ethics & Politics of Revenge
- Trudy Govier examines different attitudes toward revenge, through the voices of four characters in a coffee house.
-
Let’s Make Us Medicine of Our Great Revenge:
Revenge as a Literary Motif - Canadian novelist and biographer Joan Givner sees revenge as a “quintessential ingredient” of fiction.
fiction
- The Mime
- Joan Givner illustrates the revenge theme in a story of her own, first published here in Humanist Perspectives.
columns & departments
-
things that go bump
Justice & Revenge - Justice involves fair process; it involves a system of quid pro quo. Revenge is an individual, emotional, and often irrational matter.
-
letter from new york
From Brooklyn to Iraq:
Revenge in the Desert, Resolve in the Ring - A desire for retribution, after 9/11 was used by the Bush administration to justify the invasion of Iraq. Revenge, Diamond argues, is an ugly thing at any level.
-
films
Beyond Revenge - Shirley Goldberg writes about subtle changes to the revenge formula that are occurring, in particular, in recent French language films.
last word
- An Ethical Conundrum
- Are we really interested in rehabilitation? If so, what about our feelings about our right to mental autonomy? Robert Weyant argues that this is an ethical conundrum.
poem
- On Hearing Laurie Altman’s “Lost Child” Suite
- A nine-year-old Lebanese girl‘s comment inspired a musical composition and this poem by Judy Michaels.