Humanist Perspectives: issue 208: Restoring Realism to Citizenship and Immigration & Refugee Protection Laws

Restoring Realism to Citizenship and Immigration & Refugee Protection Laws
by Alan Danesh

Royalty-free google images

t is the supreme duty of all citizens and the Canadian leadershipto seek to protect Canadafrom the preventable evilsof tribalization and en-vironmental degradationemanating from misguid-ed laws on citizenship andimmigration which havebeen enacted based onideologies. Citizenship,immigration, and refugeeprotection laws shouldnot be shaped by the de-sires of those who aresearching for “greatness”on the international stageand at the glittering gatherings of their cliques of global elites. Those who repeat the cliché that “Canada is a nation of immigrants,” do not seem to realize that 100+ years have passed since the time when Canada was sparsely populated and in need of waves of immigrants, generally from Europe, whose contribution was essential to the development of the economy of Canada’s west.

In May, 1947, in a major speech on the federal Liberal government’s postwar immigration policy, then Canadian Prime Minister William Lyon Mackenzie King made it clear that “Canada would continue to be selective regarding which immigrants it permitted into the country....It isnot a ‘fundamental human right’ of any alien to enter Canada. It is a privilege.” Mr. King’s observation of the time, stripped of any racial or ethnic overtones, is even more valid today in a world burdened by a human population ten times the capacity of the Earth to support and when many economically advanced countries are in danger of being overrun by uncontrolled waves of economic migrants and climate refugees, and at a time when “birth tourism” and “chainimmigration” have become the common practice. A land with open borders is not a country or nation; it is an unorganized territory wide open to the masses of humanity who choose to roam through or settle in just as the Eurasian plains were invaded and settled by the tribes of the Caucasus and Central Asia that had exceeded the capacity of their original homelands to sustain their living due to overpopulation.

Citizenship, immigration, and refugee protection laws should not be shaped by the desires of those who are searching for “greatness” on the international stage...

Hence the following recommendations for reform of Canada’s Citizenship and Immigration and Refugee Protection laws:

Clause 3 (1) of Citizenship Act to be revised to read:

3 (1) Subject to this Act, a person is a citizen if :

  1. the person was born in Canada after February 14, 1977, and at the time of his birth his birth mother was a Canadian citizen;

Clauses 12 (1), (3), and 13 (1) of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act to be repealed and replaced with the following:

All immigration and refugee applicants and family reunification and sponsored applicants must be selected strictly on the basis of the individual merit system in effect at the time of their application. However, applicants who are sponsored by Canadian citizens or corporations, family reunification applicants, and refugee claimants will have their application moved forward for expedited assessment.

To implement the above recommendations, the Canadian Government must withdraw from certain international conventions that no longer reflect the realities of a drastically changed world in the interest of protecting the Canadian society from being burdened by unqualified immigrants who would prove a serious burden on Canadian society and the environment.

Under drastically altered global circumstances, Canadian politicians can no longer sustain the illusion of being the “Saviours of the World.”

Currently the global population increases at the rate of some 80 million annually. With dramatic climate changes predicted by credible scientific data, the world can expect some 2 billion climate refugees in the next 20 years. The federal government’s current proposal to significantly increase immigration intake is profoundly misguided and ensures degradation of life and the natural environment in Canada.

The population pyramid cannot be constantly enlarged at the bottom, based on the ill-conceived assumption that there always has to be a larger ratio of young working people to support the older population at the higher strata of thepopulation pyramid. To design immigration and citizenship policy based on such an assumption would be to lock Canada into the destructive logic of a rapidly increasing population with the consequent results of crowded cities, resource depletion, polluted environment and, ultimately, ecological collapse and social disintegration.

A sound immigration policy would require the admissionofnomorethan0.004%ofCanada’s current population from among qualified immigration applicants annually, to a maximum of 144,000 selected strictly on the basis of their ability to meaningfully contribute to Canadian society socially and economically. In light of the current birthrate of 1.6 children per woman in Canada, such a rate of immigration will ensure that Canada’s current population of some 36 million will remain stable in the foreseeable future.

lan Danesh is a Canadian political scientist and jurist trained in European Law who lives in Victoria, BC.


Speaking truth to power in King Lear
by Gwyneth Evans (Issue 207)
Freedom of speech is a theme throughout this play. We contradict the powerful only at our peril....
Editorial: Do you celebrate diversity (and mass immigration) or are you an unreconstructed knuckle-dragging bigot?
by Madeline Weld (Issue 206)
"Conservative Member of Parliament Maxime Bernier boldly stepped into a sacred cow patty on August 12th. In a series of six tweets, he questioned Canada?s ever-increasing diversity that he says will ?divide us into little tribes? and bring ?distrust, social conflict and potentially violence.?"
Free-speech and propaganda
by James Alcock (Issue 207)
"As Benjamin Franklin said, without free speech there can be no true liberty. We must guard against threats to our freedom while at the same time remembering that lies and propaganda are instruments that can enslave us."...
Debunking the Ivy League Mythology
by Barry Mayhew (Issue 208)
An adage one frequently hears, both within and outside academia, is as follows: “You can always tell a Harvard man but you can’t tell him very much.” Harvard graduates, and graduates from the other so-called “Ivy League” universities... also enjoy a level of status that is considerably above that associated with most other North American institutions of higher learning..... A question one might raise is: “Why is this?” and, equally significant, “Does this enviable reputation have any validity?” ...
Social Justice Warriors’ War Against the Enlightenment
by Lorna Salzman (Issue 206)
"The Enlightenment of the 18th century, whose principles enabled the rise of secular democracy, egalitarianism and human rights, was made flesh in the French Revolution and inscribed in our Constitution as the foundation of our country?s statutes and political identity. It also made possible the scientific revolution that began in the previous century even as it provoked persecution of scientific free-thinkers by the Catholic Church, whose doctrines and power structures were directly threatened."
Editorial: Free speech and its discontents
by Gary Bauslaugh (Issue 207)
Free speech is complicated; this issue of Humanist Perspectives attempts to illuminate some aspects of the matter....

order a copy of this issue (208)

$7.50 CAD, to a Canadian address
$7.50 USD, to an address in the USA
$11.50 USD, to an address outside Canada/USA
To receive a free sample copy of a previous issue, send your address to: